The Secret Economy of Abandoned Newsletters

Did you know that 85% of high-authority newsletters on platforms like Substack and Beehiiv are not actually written by the person whose face is on the banner? It is a startling reality of the creator economy: founders are brilliant at building audiences but notoriously terrible at maintaining them. This creates a massive, high-paying gap for what I call the Ghost Curator—a role that is currently paying savvy digital entrepreneurs upwards of $4,500 per month for just a few hours of work each week.

📹 Watch the video above to learn more!

Most people think the only way to make money with a newsletter is to build your own from scratch, which takes years of grinding. Here is the thing: the real money isn’t in building the car; it’s in being the driver for someone who already owns a Ferrari but doesn’t have the time to take it out of the garage. You aren’t just a writer; you are a strategic asset who keeps the founder’s brand alive while they focus on their primary business.

What Exactly is a Ghost Curator?

A Ghost Curator is a specialized content strategist who takes over the management, curation, and distribution of an existing newsletter for a busy founder, CEO, or influencer. Unlike a traditional ghostwriter who writes long-form essays, a curator focuses on information synthesis. You find the best links, summarize the latest industry news, and package it into a 5-minute read that makes the founder look like a genius every Tuesday morning.

It is the ultimate high-leverage micro-business. You don’t need to worry about SEO, you don’t need to buy ads, and you don’t need to deal with customer support. You are simply managing a digital asset that is already parked in thousands of inboxes. The founder keeps the authority, and you keep a hefty monthly retainer. Let me show you why this is the most underrated income stream of 2024.

The High-Value Leverage of Time

For a founder running a $500k-a-year agency, their time is worth roughly $250 per hour. If they spend four hours a week researching and writing a newsletter, that is $1,000 of ‘lost’ time every single week. By paying you $1,500 a month to handle it, they are actually saving $2,500 in opportunity costs. It is one of the easiest ‘yes’ decisions a business owner will ever make.

The Power of Existing Distribution

When you start your own project, your biggest enemy is zero. Zero subscribers, zero views, zero revenue. When you step in as a Ghost Curator, you are stepping into a warm audience. You get instant feedback, instant data, and the satisfaction of seeing your work reach 5,000 or 50,000 people from day one. This makes the work significantly more rewarding and provides immediate proof of concept for your skills.

How to Launch Your Ghost Curator Business in 5 Steps

You don’t need a fancy degree or a massive following of your own to start this. You just need a system. Follow these steps to land your first $1,500/month client within the next 30 days.

Step 1: Identify the ‘Zombie’ Newsletters

Your best prospects are founders who have a large following on LinkedIn or X (Twitter) but haven’t sent a newsletter in over three weeks. Use a tool like Reletter to find newsletters that have gone cold. Look for professionals in high-margin niches like SaaS, Real Estate, or B2B Consulting. These individuals have the budget to pay you and the pain of a ‘dead’ asset that needs reviving.

Step 2: The Value-First Audit

Before you reach out, perform a ‘Ghost Audit.’ Look at their last three issues. What could be better? Is the formatting messy? Is the curation lazy? Create a mock-up of what an improved version of their newsletter would look like using Beehiiv. Showing, rather than telling, is the key to bypassing the gatekeepers and getting a direct ‘yes’ from the founder.

Step 3: The ‘Trial Issue’ Pitch

Don’t ask for a job; ask for a trial. Send a brief DM or email: ‘I noticed your newsletter has been quiet lately. I’ve put together a curated draft for next Tuesday that matches your voice perfectly. Can I send it over for you to look at? If you like it, we can talk about me taking this off your plate entirely.’ This low-friction approach removes all the risk for the founder.

Step 4: Build Your Curation Engine

Once you land the client, you need to work fast. Use Feedly or Readwise Reader to aggregate the top news in your client’s niche. Set up Google Alerts for specific keywords. Spend 60 minutes on Monday morning gathering the ‘gold,’ and 60 minutes on Monday afternoon drafting the email. By using ChatGPT-4o to help summarize long articles into the founder’s specific tone, you can cut your production time in half without losing quality.

Step 5: Monetize the Back-end

The best part? You can eventually negotiate a performance bonus. If you grow the newsletter or secure a sponsorship through a platform like Paved, you can ask for a percentage of the ad revenue. This turns a flat $1,500 retainer into a $2,500+ monthly income stream from a single client.

Realistic Earnings and Timelines

Let’s talk numbers. A standard Ghost Curator retainer ranges from $1,000 to $2,500 per month per client. Most curators find that 3 clients is the ‘sweet spot’—earning you $3,000 to $7,500 monthly while only requiring about 10-15 hours of work per week.

Regarding the timeline, you can realistically earn your first dollar within 14 to 21 days. The first week is for research, the second for outreach, and the third for your first paid trial or retainer. Because you are selling to businesses (B2B), the sales cycle is much faster than trying to sell a $20 digital product to a cold audience.

Your Ghost Curator Toolkit

• Beehiiv: The best platform for managing and growing modern newsletters.
• Reletter: For finding ‘dead’ or underperforming newsletters to pitch.
• Swapstack/Paved: To find sponsors and prove your ROI to the client.
• ChatGPT-4o: For tone-matching and summarizing complex industry reports.
• Loom: To send video pitches that show the founder exactly how you’ll improve their asset.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Losing the Founder’s Voice

The biggest mistake is making the newsletter sound like a corporate robot. You must spend time reading the founder’s past posts. Do they use emojis? Do they like short, punchy sentences? If you lose their ‘vibe,’ the audience will unsubscribe, and you’ll lose the client.

Over-Automating the Process

While AI is a great assistant, don’t let it do 100% of the work. A Ghost Curator’s value is in taste. AI has no taste. You must be the one to decide which three links are actually worth the reader’s time. If you provide junk, you are no longer a curator; you are just a spammer.

Neglecting the Metrics

Founders care about two things: open rates and click-through rates. If you aren’t tracking these and reporting them back to the founder once a month, they will eventually forget why they are paying you. Always lead with the data.

Ready to Become a Ghost Curator?

The world is full of brilliant people who are too busy to be consistent. Your job is to be that consistency. The Ghost Curator method is the most direct path to a mid-four-figure income without the headaches of traditional freelancing. Your next step is simple: Go to LinkedIn, find three founders in a niche you enjoy, and check if they have a ‘dead’ newsletter link in their bio. Your first $1,500 retainer is waiting for you in their neglected inbox.